Can Orthodoxy Decide Its Own History?
In his 2004 review of Rabbi Nosson Kamenetsky’s controversy-sparking Making of a Godol, Professor Mordechai Breuer notes a marked change happening within haredi culture, specifically book culture: The contents of the traditional Haredi bookshelf have expanded and transformed beyond recognition in recent generations. Alongside … the rabbinic classics … the shelves are now filled with books of types our ancestors could not have imagined. Breuer is referring to the proliferation of a new form of biography, or hagiography, of gedolim,…