Daf Yomi: Seforim on Moed Katan, Part Two and Three
Daf Yomi: Seforim on Moed Katan, Part Two and Three
By Eliezer Brodt
Daf Yomi is in middle of learning Masseches Moed Katan. This week I had two conversations with Rabbi Moshe Schwed of All Daf. The purpose of these conversation were for me to trace the concerns for the fear some had to learn this Masechtah, especially the section devoted to Avelius as it deals with topics related to death.
Part two deals with tracing the sources about this from the Sefer Chasdim, Yosef Ometz and the Chasam Sofer. Some other Mesechtas were added to the list by various sources. I than traced the learning of this topic until the end of the Rishonim period, including a close examination of the significance of the Toras HaAdam of the Ramban.
Part three picks up with the Achronim period. Looking more closely at the Curriculum in Lita, and Volozhin. I continued on with some more contemporary Poskim’s views about learning this subject and conclude with a short bibliography of various seforim on Aveilus.
We recorded them and they are available for viewing: part two is here and here. Part three is here and here.
Part two is forty- seven minutes, which is much longer than most of the previous ones. I apologize for the length in advance, luckily both links have options for one to listen on fast speed! Part three is only 23 minutes long. Many aspects could have been discussed at much greater length but R. Schwed had mercy on potential listeners!
This is an experiment which we are trying on the Seforim Blog and we hope to have other presentations from others over time. Feedback or comments of any sort are appreciated.
This is the seventh and eighth such conversation I have had with him of this kind this year (earlier we discussed Yerushalmi Shekalim [here], Yoma [here], Rosh Hashanah [here] Taanis [here] Megillah [here] and Moed Koton part one [here]).
5 thoughts on “Daf Yomi: Seforim on Moed Katan, Part Two and Three”
Great!
I hope Rabbi Brodt will continue this throughout ש״ס including the so called “yeshivishe mesechtos”. It really adds much to my learning when I understand the background of the texts I’m studying.
Who published the new edition of toras haodom? You just showed it but didn’t say where to get it
Thanks again for the interesting and informative discussions.
Regarding the סדר הלימוד in volozhin, R’ Aharon Mylikovski in his sefer אהלי אהרן ח”ב עמ’ ר”ה writes very clearly that shiurim were given on the entire sha”s besides for zeraim and teharos (the words zeraim and teharos are written זו”ט and even though the ט looks more like a מwhich could lead one to understand it to mean zeraim and moed , I think it is pretty simple that it’s more likely that the mesechtas on which their is no gemara were left out of the cycle.)
Who is the author of Tosfot in Moed Katan? And what are all the references he makes to ” Tosfot” and “Tosfot HaRav”? I did a computer search and found 26 examples of this. This seems unique in Shas. I did a search in the rest of Shas and found only 19 examples or so. I’ll send the file if you like.
Enjoying your lectures on AllDaf.
Excellent introduction to the mesechta. I am eagerly waiting for introductions to upcoming mesechtas, the longer the better.