1

Latest MOAG Ban Runs Counter to an Agreement with R. Eliyashiv

A reader has sent me the following letter from R. Kamenstky discussing the possiblity of a ban on the improved edition of MOAG. The letter says “if people will come to complain to R. Eliasiv about the new edition and say such and such is written there, he will not listen to them until he first calls me, and I will need to present when they translate my book for him.”

Additionally, I have received the following relevant information.

“The letter quotes Rav Elyashiv as saying that the request that the author should be called and given a fair chance to defend himself is just. This was repeated by a number of meetings that the author had with R’ Elyashiv. Before the letter was sent out it was shown to Aryeh Elyashiv – the grandson in charge of all the appointments and present in the room during all meetings to assist his grandfather – and he stated that the quote was correct and it conveys faithfully his grandfather’s say on the matter.

The letter was delivered to the following Rabbis:
Steinman
Sheinberg
Karelitz
Kanyevsky
Markowitz
Auerbach
It was not sent to Rabbi Shapiro because he already apologized for the first time that he signed against the book, and had already said that he will not have anything more to do with this affair. Sure enough he kept his word now and didn’t sign.
R’ Wolbe was omitted because he’s not alive.
R’ Elyashiv didn’t have to receive this letter because he was the subject of the letter.
R’ Lefkowitz was not sent this letter because he was very vicious the time before, and could not be expected to be fair.

The author has made it his habit to daven in the morning in R’ Elyashiv’s minyan from time to time, so that if anything arises he can be informed of immediately.

This last Friday and Sunday he was at the minyan and no one (including Yisroel Elyashiv – another grandson) said anything when asked if everything is fine. It was only after he came home that he found out about the ad and article in Yated Neeman.”